Article Summary: The Ten Star Thought Experiment uses extreme ideas to unlock practical and remarkable experience improvements.
This is inspired by Brian Chesky, Co-Founder of Airbnb, who often talks about the thought experiment he ran when designing the Airbnb customer experience.
When people rate their Airbnb stay, five stars basically just means nothing bad happened. It’s a pretty low bar.
And this fits in with our definition of what constitutes a 5/10 experience: ‘A perfectly adequate, low customer effort service, not an experience, leaving people feeling neutral, indifferent and unsurprised. Meets expectations, common, and a classic plateau.’
If you were rating an Airbnb stay or an Uber ride, you’d probably rate it a ‘5’ if, as Chesky puts it, ‘nothing bad happened’.
But you definitely wouldn’t tell your friends about it.
A ‘5’ on our ‘Experience Rating Scale’ means that 0% of customers will retell any story.
So the Airbnb Co-Founder challenged himself to design a six star experience, then seven, then eight, then nine and finally a ten star experience.
It gets completely unrealistic, but it’s a useful exercise.
The point here isn’t to create a ten star experience.
The point is to use the often impossible ten star experience as inspiration.
In ‘Outside In’, Lou Carbone and James H. Gilmore say ‘it’s easier to make a profound idea reasonable than it is to make a reasonable idea profound.’
You might get lucky and land on an absolutely astounding ten star idea that you can implement.
But even if you don’t, you will be scaling up a plateau to something much more impactful and memorable.
For each of your plateau touch points, ask yourself what it would look like if it was six star. Once that’s done, what would it look like if it was seven? Then eight, nine and ten.
It’s important not to go straight to ten and skip the other steps. They’re important to help ‘ramp up’ the ‘remarkability’ of each touch point.
Your Action Steps
- Choose one plateau touch point in your customer experience.
- Ask what a six star version would look like.
- Continue through seven, eight, nine and ten stars.
- Use the impossible ten star idea as inspiration for something practical and memorable.